Independent investing education · No ads · No affiliate links · Not financial advice

News analysis ·

Roth 401(k) rules: no lifetime RMDs and the heir clock

A Kiplinger column revisits the Roth 401(k). We explain the SECURE 2.0 RMD rule, the 10-year heir rule and how to test the math at enrollment.

Torn photo of a brass hourglass with sand running, taped beside a plum paper scrap reading The heir clock over an old map scrap.
Photo: John Morgan / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0 (cropped)

A Kiplinger column published on 2026-10-26 argues that many workers overlook the Roth option in their 401(k), even though most employers now offer it. The author, a former retirement industry consultant, counts himself among the workers who stayed pretax. This article looks at the rules behind that argument, what the column's worked example does and does not show, and the checks a saver can run before annual enrollment closes.

What the Kiplinger column found

According to Kiplinger, a Roth 401(k) is available at 95% of employers, yet under 20% of employees use it. The author counts himself among the 80% who stayed pretax. Roth accounts inside 401(k) plans only became possible in 2006, and many employers were slow to add them, so a large share of Boomers and Gen Xers never had the choice during their peak saving years.

The column also cites Fidelity data showing a 41% annual rise in Roth conversions in Q1 2026. The author reads that as savers who built up pretax balances now trying to move money into tax-free territory.

Kiplinger labels the piece as the view of a contributing adviser in its Adviser Intel program, not its editorial staff. It points readers to SEC or FINRA records to vet any adviser, which is a sensible habit for any column of this kind.

The rules that shape the Roth choice

A pretax contribution lowers your taxable income today, and you pay income tax when you withdraw. A Roth contribution is made with money that has already been taxed, and qualified withdrawals later are tax-free. As the column's author puts it, with pretax saving "you're not just deferring tax on what you put in, you're deferring it on everything that money earns for decades."

Two legal rules make the difference sharper. First, required minimum distributions, or RMDs, are yearly withdrawals the tax code forces from many retirement accounts. Under the SECURE 2.0 Act, since 2024 the person who opened a Roth 401(k), or a Roth IRA, does not have to take RMDs from it while alive.

Second, inheritance rules changed. For non-spouse heirs, the option to spread inherited withdrawals over their own lifetime largely ended starting in 2020. They must now empty an inherited pretax account within 10 years. Pretax money that comes out in a short window is taxable income for the heir. The author inherited a traditional IRA in 2018, before the change, and still found that each required withdrawal raised his taxable income.

Reading the worked example carefully

The column's example uses a $100,000 salary with no raises, a 6% employee contribution, a 4% employer match, 40 years of saving, a 5% annual return, Florida residence, a 22% federal rate while working and 15% in retirement. Both paths end with a total balance at 65 of $1,268,398.

The key line is what is taxable. On the Roth path only the $507,359 match balance is taxed, because roughly one plan in five offers a Roth match today and the column assumes the match stays pretax. On the pretax path the full $1,268,398 is taxable. Tax owed is $76,103 versus $190,259, leaving after-tax assets of $1,192,295 versus $1,078,139, a gap of $114,156. At a 7% return the gap grows to $192,249.

Notice the cost side too. The same $6,000 yearly contribution cuts take-home pay by $6,000 under Roth but by $4,680 pretax, because pretax saving brings a $1,320 yearly federal tax saving. The column says a pretax saver who invests that saving would narrow the gap. Its figures are hypothetical, ignore fees and charges, and assume equal dollar contributions. Real returns are not fixed, and a retirement balance can fall as well as rise, so you can lose money.

State tax can flip the result. Working in a high-tax state and retiring to a no-tax state can favour pretax. The reverse can expose pretax money to both federal and state tax. Withdrawals also need grossing up: to net $10,000 from a pretax 401(k) in a 15% bracket, a retiree must take out $11,765, while a Roth holder takes out $10,000.

How to protect yourself

The Roth question is a tax bet on your future, so it pays to test it rather than follow a rule of thumb.

  • Check whether your plan offers Roth contributions and whether its match is pretax or Roth, in the plan's summary documents.
  • Compare your current tax bracket with a realistic estimate for retirement, including the state you expect to live in.
  • If you choose pretax, note what happens to the yearly tax saving, since the column says investing it would narrow the Roth gap.
  • Review beneficiaries and think about the 10-year rule for any non-spouse heir who could inherit a pretax balance.

If you use an adviser to run the numbers, look up their record with the SEC or FINRA first.

What happens next

The author suggests using this year's annual enrollment window to decide, and notes that Roth and pretax can be combined rather than treated as all or nothing. He also advises running personal numbers with a tax accountant or financial adviser. Future tax rates are unknown, which is why the column's figures are only an illustration.

Sources

An AI model drafted this from the official notices and reports listed above. It was published automatically after software checks on figures and wording, without a human edit. It describes rules and protective habits; it is not personal financial advice.

← All posts