Independent investing education · No ads · No affiliate links · Not financial advice

News analysis ·

Retirement tax traps: IRA withholding and IRMAA

Kiplinger lists five retirement tax traps. We explain the IRA withholding default, the IRMAA lookback and the earnings test, plus the checks that help.

Photo of the long colonnaded Internal Revenue Service building in Washington, DC, under a blue sky, framed on a plum ground
Photo: Carol M. Highsmith / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain (cropped)

Kiplinger published a list of five lesser-known tax traps that tend to catch people in their early years of retirement. Most of them are not new rules but defaults and lookback formulas that work quietly in the background. This article explains how each mechanism works and which simple checks help a new retiree avoid a surprise bill.

What Kiplinger flagged

The common thread in the Kiplinger list is that a paycheck used to do a lot of tax work for you. Once it stops, employer withholding stops too, and the retiree becomes responsible for taxes on every income stream: IRA withdrawals, Social Security, part-time work and investment income.

The traps Kiplinger describes cover the Social Security earnings test, Medicare premium surcharges, default withholding on IRA withdrawals, the way the IRS counts income for benefit taxation, and housing costs that can outpace the yearly cost-of-living adjustment. Kiplinger notes that its piece covers federal income tax and municipal property tax only, that state rules may differ, and that a qualified tax professional can help when the picture gets complicated.

The default that does the most damage: IRA withholding

Most money taken out of a traditional IRA counts as ordinary income, taxed at federal and state rates. According to Kiplinger, IRA custodians generally withhold a flat 10% for federal tax by default and often withhold nothing for state tax unless the account holder asks for something different.

A default is not a recommendation. It is simply what happens when nobody fills in the form. If a retiree's real tax rate is higher than the default, the gap shows up later as a tax bill, and possibly as underpayment penalties. Kiplinger gives an example of setting withholding at 22% federal and 6% state, and notes that quarterly estimated payments are another route.

Lookbacks and hidden income: IRMAA and combined income

Medicare Part B and Part D premiums can carry a surcharge called the income-related monthly adjustment amount, or IRMAA. The key detail is timing. Medicare uses a two-year lookback on tax returns, so a big IRA withdrawal, selling a house or a high final working year can raise premiums two years later, when income may already be much lower.

There is a correction path. After a qualifying life event such as work stoppage, a retiree can file Form SSA-44 with the Social Security Administration and ask for premiums based on current, lower income.

A second trap is how income is counted. MAGI, short for modified adjusted gross income, drives several thresholds, including IRMAA, whether traditional IRA contributions are deductible, and the net investment income tax. It includes dividends, income earned abroad and muni bond interest that is otherwise tax-exempt. Separately, the IRS uses combined income to decide how much of a Social Security benefit is taxed. Once that figure passes $25,000 on a single return, or $32,000 on a joint return, up to 50% to 85% of benefits can become taxable. Kiplinger notes that qualified Roth IRA or Roth 401(k) distributions are tax-free and count toward neither measure.

The earnings test is a delay, not a loss

Social Security can be claimed from age 62, while full retirement age is typically 66 to 67 depending on birth year. Claiming early cuts the monthly check by 25% to 30%. For 2026, someone below full retirement age for the whole year who earns more than $24,480 has $1 held back for each $2 of pay over the limit.

It is easy to read that as a penalty. "It's a temporary withholding, not a penalty." That is how Kiplinger puts it. At full retirement age the benefit is recalculated higher to credit the held-back amounts, although how much comes back depends on how long the person lives.

Housing costs are the last trap. Social Security COLAs follow CPI-W, an index built on working-age spending, so property tax and utility increases can outrun the yearly adjustment. Kiplinger points to homestead exemptions, property tax freezes and rebates for older adults, or a cash cushion, so that spikes do not force extra traditional IRA withdrawals.

How to protect yourself

The protective habit here is the same one Token Atlas recommends for any account: never assume a default setting was chosen with your situation in mind. A few checks cover most of the risk.

  • Before any IRA withdrawal, look at the withholding election on the form and set federal and state amounts that match your own expected tax rate.
  • Before a big one-off income event, such as a home sale or a large withdrawal, remember the two-year Medicare lookback and plan the timing with that in mind.
  • If your income dropped because you stopped working, keep proof of the date and ask about Form SSA-44 if a premium surcharge arrives.
  • When estimating taxes on benefits, add back tax-exempt interest and other income that counts toward MAGI and combined income, rather than looking only at taxable income.

None of these checks requires a product, only careful reading of forms and good records.

What to watch next

The earnings test limit cited by Kiplinger applies to 2026, so retirees still working part-time should check the figure each year rather than relying on an old number. Because state rules differ, anyone with a complicated mix of accounts may want a qualified tax professional to review withholding before filing season.

Sources

An AI model drafted this from the official notices and reports listed above. It was published automatically after software checks on figures and wording, without a human edit. It describes rules and protective habits; it is not personal financial advice.

← All posts