Independent investing education · No ads · No affiliate links · Not financial advice

News analysis ·

Retirement adviser red flags: how to vet a planner

A Kiplinger column lists 10 adviser red flags for retirees with pensions. We explain the RMD, IRMAA and annuity checks and how to test an adviser.

A black fountain pen lies on a printed contract, next to empty signature, name and date lines, in soft side light.
Photo: Blogtrepreneur / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0 (cropped)

Kiplinger published a contributed column on 2026-10-28 listing 10 red flags retirees should watch for when judging a financial adviser. The author, a planner who runs his own firm, argues that many advisers manage a portfolio well but skip the rest of the plan. Here we look at which warning signs a saver can test, and what the column itself teaches about reading advice.

What the column said

The piece ran through the Kiplinger Adviser Intel network, a group of outside professionals who write for the site. Kiplinger says it reflects the adviser's views, not its editorial staff. The writer holds the CFP mark and leads his own firm, Peak Retirement Planning.

His core warning is simple. Investment management is only one part of retirement. Taxes, required minimum distributions (RMDs), Medicare costs and estate issues matter just as much for a household with a pension and a large IRA.

The warning signs, grouped by what they cost you

The 10 flags fall into a few groups. The first group is about taxes. An RMD is the amount the tax code forces you to withdraw each year from a traditional IRA or similar account once you reach a set age. The column gives a rough illustration: at about 4%, $500,000 in tax-deferred accounts produces about $20,000 of taxable income, while $3 million produces about $120,000. The percentage also rises with age.

That is why the author is wary of an adviser who dismisses Roth conversions without modeling them. A conversion moves money from a pre-tax account to a Roth account, and you pay tax on the amount moved. His example is a retiree with a $75,000 pension, Social Security and several million dollars in an IRA, whose future RMDs could stack taxable income on top. As he put it: "The important part isn't whether your adviser is "pro-Roth." It's whether your adviser has actually run the numbers."

Medicare is the next cost. IRMAA is a surcharge that higher earners pay on top of their Part B and Part D Medicare premiums. The income tiers are narrow, so a conversion or a large withdrawal can push premiums up sharply.

The second group is about product sales. The author flags an adviser who quickly pushes an income annuity on someone who already has a large pension. He notes annuities can carry costs, limits and reduced liquidity, and says he has seen retirees told to put a very large share of their assets into one anyway. A pension already does much of that job. A $50,000 yearly pension paid for 20 years equals $1 million of income before any cost-of-living adjustments.

The rest cover follow-through: claiming to do tax planning without coordinating tax preparation, lacking CFP certification, not helping put the estate plan in place, and ignoring Medicare, Social Security and early retirement.

Reading the advice behind the advice

There is a protective lesson in the column's own setup. The author promotes a free book and his own firm, which requires its advisers to hold or pursue the CFP certification. That does not make the list wrong, but one of his flags, lacking CFP certification, matches his own firm's rule for its advisers. Savers should read every adviser checklist the same way: useful questions, written by someone with a business interest.

The same habit applies to the adviser sitting across the table. Ask how they are paid before you weigh what they recommend. An adviser paid a commission on an annuity has a reason to recommend one. A fiduciary, by contrast, must put your interest ahead of their own. The author himself concedes that a designation alone does not make someone a great adviser, and that not everyone should do a Roth conversion.

His withdrawal example shows why this matters. With $3 million saved, Social Security of $50,000 and a pension paying $50,000, a household needing $150,000 a year takes only $50,000 from the portfolio, under a 2% withdrawal rate. A plan built on those numbers looks very different from one built around selling more lifetime-income products. Ask whether your adviser starts from your income needs or from a product.

How to protect yourself

Before you hand over a retirement account, or while reviewing the adviser you have, run these checks.

  • Look up the adviser's record in the SEC and FINRA databases, including any disciplinary history and the firm they work for.
  • Ask in writing how the adviser is paid, and whether they act as a fiduciary for every recommendation, including insurance products.
  • Ask to see a written projection of your future RMDs and how a Roth conversion would change your tax and Medicare costs.
  • If an annuity is proposed, ask what problem it solves that your pension does not, and get its costs and withdrawal limits on paper.

What happens next

The column does not report a rule change or an enforcement case. It is a checklist, and it ends by reminding readers that the SEC and FINRA keep records on advisers they can check. The practical step is to bring the list to your next review. Estate follow-through is a good final test: correct account titling, current beneficiary designations and properly funded trusts where appropriate.

Sources

An AI model drafted this from the official notices and reports listed above. It was published automatically after software checks on figures and wording, without a human edit. It describes rules and protective habits; it is not personal financial advice.

← All posts