Independent investing education · No ads · No affiliate links · Not financial advice

News analysis ·

Inherited IRA tax rules: the 10-year clock and penalties

CNBC and Kiplinger outline inherited IRA tax rules. We explain the 10-year clock, the 25% missed-RMD penalty and four checks heirs can make.

Black-and-white close-up of an old adding machine keyboard, with purple rings stepping down the key columns and an arrow leading to the ringed crank handle
Photo: Daderot / Wikimedia Commons, CC0 (cropped, black and white)

Two reports published on October 27 walk through the tax side of inheriting an IRA. CNBC cited Vanguard data showing that heirs are typically 59 when they inherit, and Kiplinger set out the federal and state rules that decide how much of the account they keep. This article sorts those rules into the order an heir should check them, and looks at the penalty that catches people most easily.

What the new reports found

According to CNBC, a recent Vanguard study looked at nearly 83,000 inherited accounts in 2024. The mean balance was $128,000. At 59, an heir is often still working, so withdrawals can land on top of a salary.

The stakes are growing. CNBC pointed to a 2025 UBS report that puts transfers between generations at about $74 trillion over the next 20 to 25 years. Inherited accounts come with their own deadlines, which is why the rules matter.

How the 10-year rule and yearly RMDs work

Since 2020, certain heirs, including adult children, generally have to empty an inherited account by the 10th year after the original owner's death. Kiplinger gave an example: if the owner dies in 2026 and the standard ten-year rule applies, the account generally must be empty by December 31, 2036.

The clock is not the only rule. A required minimum distribution, or RMD, is a withdrawal the tax law makes you take each year. CNBC reported that since 2025, some adult-child heirs must take yearly RMDs inside the 10-year window if the owner had already reached RMD age, usually 73.

Some heirs are outside the 10-year rule. Kiplinger listed these eligible designated beneficiaries: surviving spouses, the owner's minor children until adulthood, disabled or chronically ill people, and heirs no more than ten years younger than the owner.

Reading the penalties: which one is the real trap

Many savers know the 10% early withdrawal penalty for people under 59½. Kiplinger noted that it generally does not apply to inherited IRA payouts, whatever the heir's age. So a younger heir is not punished for taking money early.

The bigger risk runs the other way. Kiplinger said missing a required withdrawal can cost 25% of the shortfall as a federal penalty. In other words, the penalty that matters for heirs is for taking too little, too late, not too much, too soon. An heir who assumes the full decade is free time, when yearly RMDs may apply, risks that penalty.

Taxes on the withdrawal itself depend on the account type. Money taken out of an inherited traditional IRA is usually taxed as ordinary income. Qualified payouts from an inherited Roth IRA are usually free of federal tax, though deadlines can still apply.

Timing and state taxes

CNBC noted that withdrawals from a pretax inherited IRA raise adjusted gross income, which can raise the tax bill and cut eligibility for other tax breaks. Waiting is not a cure either, because it can force one large withdrawal in the 10th year. Kiplinger's example: taking a $300,000 inherited traditional IRA in a single year on top of a large salary could push part of that income into a higher marginal bracket.

Planner James Mayo of IronFjord Wealth Management told CNBC: "I recommend projecting income over those 10 years and planning withdrawals around it." He pointed to low-income years, such as retirement or a sabbatical, as windows for larger withdrawals.

State rules add a second layer. Kiplinger listed five states with an inheritance tax: Kentucky, Maryland, Nebraska, New Jersey and Pennsylvania. Twelve states and the District of Columbia levy estate taxes. In Pennsylvania, the inheritance tax rate depends on the relationship: 0% for a surviving spouse, 4.5% for direct descendants, 12% for siblings and 15% for most others, including friends.

How to protect yourself

A few checks before the first withdrawal can prevent most surprises.

  • Confirm your beneficiary category first. It decides whether the 10-year clock applies to you at all.
  • Ask whether the owner had reached RMD age before death. If so, yearly withdrawals may be required, and a missed one can draw the 25% penalty.
  • Check whether the account is traditional or Roth, and whether your state or the owner's state taxes the money.
  • Sketch your expected income for each year of the window, as planner James Mayo suggests, and see which years are lower-income.

Kiplinger stressed that its guide is general information, not individual tax or legal advice, and suggested a tax professional for large balances.

What happens next

The clock starts at the owner's death, so deadlines such as December 31, 2036 in Kiplinger's example arrive whether or not an heir has made a plan. Owners also have levers. Tim Steffen of Baird told CNBC that owners can weigh each heir's tax bracket, for example leaving more IRA money to a lower-earning child and tax-free life insurance to a higher earner. CFP Dinon Hughes said Roth conversions during the owner's life can help heirs, but a conversion raises income in that year. That extra income can affect the $6,000 senior bonus deduction and Medicare IRMAA surcharges, so the trade-off needs a projection before any move.

Sources

An AI model drafted this from the official notices and reports listed above. It was published automatically after software checks on figures and wording, without a human edit. It describes rules and protective habits; it is not personal financial advice.

← All posts